The Supreme Court at 150

The Supreme Court of Canada turns 150 this year! From modest beginnings in 1875, the Supreme Court has evolved into the trusted final authority on Canadian law and the Constitution. Learn more about the Court’s early days.

Presented in collaboration with Library and Archives Canada and the Senate of Canada.

The former Supreme Court building on the western edge of Parliament Hill, with the Centre Block building in the background.

Former Supreme Court building on the western edge of Parliament Hill
Late 1800s
Topley Studio, Library and Archives Canada, a008389

On this page

Founding an institution

The Fathers of Confederation intended “a General Court of Appeal,” but Parliament only established such a court in 1875 after 2 previous attempts. Until 1949, however, the Court’s decisions could be appealed to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in London, United Kingdom.

Parliament rejected an early Supreme Court proposal in 1869; critics worried that the court would have no Francophone judges and would unfairly strengthen federal power.

A draft of the Supreme Court Bill, entitled “An Act to establish a Supreme Court for the Dominion of Canada”.

Draft of Supreme Court Bill
1869
Library and Archives Canada, e011871988

The Supreme and Exchequer Court Act received royal assent on April 8, 1875. The Governor General—the Marquess of Dufferin and Ava—and the clerks of the Senate and the House of Commons signed the original French and English copies.

The first page of the Supreme and Exchequer Court Act, entitled “An Act respecting the taking of evidence for use in the Supreme Court, or the Exchequer Court, of Canada”.
The second page of the Supreme and Exchequer Court Act.

The Supreme and Exchequer Court Act
1875
Courtesy of the Senate of Canada

A handwritten document in French with the attestations and signatures of the Governor General and the clerks of the Senate and the House of Commons. The signatures are over the attestation text in all directions.
A handwritten document in English with the attestations and signatures of the Governor General and the clerks of the Senate and the House of Commons. The signatures are over the attestation text in all directions.
The proclamation of the Supreme and Exchequer Court Act, featuring 3 signatures on it.

Proclamation of The Supreme and Exchequer Court Act
1875
Library and Archives Canada, e011871986

Quebec’s Attorney-General commented on proposed amendments to the Supreme Court Act, which would have changed how the Court heard cases from his province.

A letter written in French and addressed to Sir Alexander Campbell, Minister of Justice. The letter has a handwritten annotation that reads “Ackg P.Sec”

Remarks on the Supreme Court Act by Louis-Onésime Loranger
1882
Library and Archives Canada, e011871987

Setting precedents

The Supreme Court considered important questions of the day in its first cases. Practical tasks, such as building a court library and buying furniture, also kept court staff busy.

In its first decision, on a question from Parliament, the Court ruled that incorporating a religious teaching order was a provincial, not federal, responsibility.

The Petition for Incorporation of the Society of the Brothers of the Christian Schools in Canada. It bears a date stamp from the Governor General of Canada and from the Department of the Secretary of State. A partially legible handwritten annotation reads, “March 3.76. Acknowledge + forward for action”.

Petition for Incorporation of the Society of the Brothers of the Christian Schools in Canada
1876
Library and Archives Canada, e011871984

The Court’s first appeal clarified the scope of a controversial Prince Edward Island law forcing absentee landlords to sell their land to the government.

A Supreme Court record for Kelly v. Sulivan listing the names of the judges who heard the appeal. It has a Supreme Court of Canada seal and ribbon.

Decision in Kelly v. Sulivan
1877
Library and Archives Canada, e011871985

The new Court’s mandate was ambitious, but its first expenses were modest: stamps, telegrams and cleaning supplies for the caretaker.

An accounting ledger title “Account showing amount paid for contingencies connected with the Supreme Court of Canada up to 30th June A.D. 1876”. It lists a $200 credit and several expenses, including office furniture, telegraphs and the wages of the Supreme Court of Canada caretaker, Mrs. Meyers.

Supreme Court of Canada Contingencies Account
1876
Library and Archives Canada, e011871982

Writing to the Department of Justice, the Registrar requested furniture for the Court’s quarters, including chairs for the judges.

A handwritten letter from Robert Cassels, Supreme Court Registrar to the Deputy Minister of Justice, dated January 29, 1876. It bears a date stamp from the Department of Justice.

Letter from Robert Cassells, Supreme Court Registrar, to the Deputy Minister of Justice
1876
Library and Archives Canada, e011871981

Can you find a book by Adolphe-Basile Routhier in this ledger? A respected judge and legal scholar, Routhier is best known for having written the French lyrics to O Canada.

Ledger of books purchased by the Supreme Court Library. Handwritten entries in English list several publications purchased with associated prices.

Ledger of Books Purchased for Supreme Court Library
1888–1907
Library and Archives Canada, e011871983

Proclaiming the new Constitution

The Constitution Act, 1982 gave Canada the power to amend its own foundational law without consulting the United Kingdom. See the royal proclamation that enacted the new Constitution and learn why there are 2 copies.

Queen Elizabeth II signing the Proclamation of the Constitution Act, seated at a table with Prime Minister Pierre Elliott Trudeau. Standing around them are Minister of Labour Gerald Regan, Clerk of the Privy Council Michael Pitfield and Michael Kirby.

Signing of the Proclamation of the Constitution Act, April 17, 1982
Robert Cooper, photographer
Library and Archives Canada, e008300499
© Government of Canada

Signed in duplicate

On April 17, 1982, Queen Elizabeth II signed the royal proclamation enacting the Constitution Act, 1982. The new Constitution included an amendment process and the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The Charter sets out the Supreme Court of Canada’s role as guardian of the Constitution.

The Queen signed 2 copies of the proclamation. Raindrops damaged the first copy during the ceremony, and in 1983, an activist damaged the second copy by throwing paint on it to protest missile tests in northern Canada. Unintentionally imperfect, the 2 proclamations symbolize the process of making a better country.

The “Raindrop” copy of the Proclamation of the Constitution Act. It is signed by Queen Elizabeth II, Minister of Justice Jean Chrétien, Registrar General of Canada André Ouellet and Prime Minister Pierre Elliott Trudeau. Water damage can be seen in several areas of the document.

Proclamation of the Constitution Act (“Raindrop” Copy)
1982
Library and Archives Canada, e008125379

The “Stained” copy of the Proclamation of the Constitution Act. It is signed by Queen Elizabeth II, Minister of Justice Jean Chrétien, Registrar General of Canada André Ouellet and Prime Minister Pierre Elliott Trudeau. A large, red paint stain covers the middle of the document, but the text can still be read through it.

Proclamation of the Constitution Act (“Stained” Copy)
1982
Library and Archives Canada, e008125377